WUNRN
|
Dear Friends and Colleagues,
Regrettably, this will be the last WEMC e-bulletin. For reasons beyond the control of those of us directly involved in the project, the WEMC RPC officially closed on 30 June 2010. Since the project no longer exists, in a sense this e-bulletin reaches you as the voice of the project's spirit. And perhaps that is apt.
Officially, WEMC commenced on 1 July 2006, but it started as musings by a few in late 2004 that were conjured into a proposed dream in July 2005 in the most oppressive pre-monsoon heat of Lahore (complete with electricity outages and office flooding when torrential rains finally burst asunder the skies). All of us involved in the project were infused with such deep-rooted commitment and astonishing energy, with such inspired creativity and dogged perseverance that, in a mere four years instead of five, the RPC shattered the goalposts we thought we had ambitiously set in terms of expected outputs. Tangible measureable results (OVIs for those in the know) were not merely overtaken but made irrelevant as the achievements doubled (or very nearly doubled) all expected results:
18 concrete recommendations accepted and acted upon by authorities have changed laws, policies and practices impacting more than 150,000 women - and that's not counting their families and friends. It's also not counting the amazing 27 new women's rights groups (formal and non-formal, overt or less visible, religious, secular or combining both), directly catalysed through research processes in Indonesia, Pakistan Iran, China and elsewhere, that are happily forging new innovative and indigenous strategies, multiplying manifold the voices for women's empowerment - largely women's own voices. Nor does it include countless other civil society groups, networks and alliances that have re-oriented activities to support women's empowerment strategies, or the allies and champions mobilised in diverse decision-making forums in high governmental institutions as well as at the life-determining meso-level where women daily confront the most immediate obstacles to empowerment. Numbers do not take into account the impact of changing discourses and changing everyday practices that are challenging and overturning the existing power dynamics that keep women disempowered. Nor does it account for the surprisingly impactful 15 documentary films produced by mixing a 10-day training by a professional + one follow up session + pooling expertise for self-improvement across teams, with women's creativity when they are determined to convert a dream into reality or have finally decided to air in public a grievance - when the silence is broken and women's voices can be heard.
Films have reduced audiences to tears, inspired actions for change...and are even used by authorities in their programmes.
WEMC set out to promote 'democratisation from the inside out'. Its approach of a participatory, reflexive and transformative research process is tangible evidence that when an eggshell is broken from outside, a life dies; but when the shell is broken from within, a life is indeed born...
The spirit of the WEMC project lives on through the seeds both scattered and planted and definitely nurtured with loving care in the last few years...enough energies to release and celebrate new life.
So in anticipation of new life...renewed energies...and a life beyond WEMC in the same spirit (or one quite like it) that buoyed us up and kept us together…
Farida Shaheed
__________________________________________________________________
Extracts of the Final Report for DFID,
July 2010 |
|
|
|
|
A. WEMC PURPOSE ACHIEVED Proving that research when, instead of being
extractive, is designed to be supportive and is attentive to women’s voices,
can help lever empowerment, WEMC’s legacy is its self-defined purpose
catalysing: “a sustained, growing
critical mass of civil society expertise engaged in policy debates for
long-term changes in policies and practices that promote women’s empowerment
in Muslim contexts”. Achievements have been built on a
very effective Communication Strategy, tailored to specific audience and socio-political contexts at micro,
meso and macro levels, using highly diverse modalities which effectuated
local change (catalysing and supporting women’s empowerment initiatives);
reoriented local environments to be more supportive (communicating with meso-level
policy implementers, opinion-makers, and civil society associations); helped
to bring about policy revisions. Success is visible in accepted
recommendations, authorities’ usage of outputs, the amplification of voices
for women’s empowerment through new groups/initiatives; requests and usage of
WEMC products (over 60 websites excerpt/are linked to WEMC materials). A new development paradigm is supported by research findings that a
rights-based development approach resonates deeply with the new paradigm of
‘development with culture’ proposed by the UN Indigenous Peoples Forum.
Research suggests there is merit in developing such an approach for women’s
empowerment - especially when women suffer from severe exclusion. Similar
concerns arise: not merely making services more accessible but strengthening
women’s own institutions, not development on behalf of but with, women, and
an understanding that success can “depend critically on how one goes about
development rather than simply on the choice of the subject matter of a
specific intervention.” This last applies to research processes and
interventions equally. |
||
B. LESSONS AND CONCLUSIONS
Policy
Planning lessons
Policies must help overcome the ‘cost of empowerment’ which women identify;
understand that empowerment initiatives do not emerge from individual women
accessing better services but from collectivised actions for which women
prioritise public discursive spaces; that empowerment cannot be achieved
without addressing meso-level dynamics where access to information, resources
and decision-making forums is most obstructed and justified through
misogynistic interpretations of culture and religion; that in negotiating
rights collectively, women position themselves variously - making it vital to
assess the impact of the contested changing constructions of Muslimness and
other other social identities and the interplay amongst these to draw lessons
for citizenship and governance/ development planning.
Research
Lessons : A unifying framework & diversifying realities
With a consistent focus on power as central to discourses on women’s
empowerment, a main feature of the WEMC RPC was the dialogic relationship
between a coherent and explicitly conceptualised research framework (RF) as a
unifying factor on the one hand, and grounded, context-specific field research
to bring forth contextualised understandings and actions on the other. The core
research questions, addressing four thematic areas of the WEMC RF stimulated
enquiries and analyses about women’s understandings of the power relations in
which they are embedded; adapting the RF to contextual specificities engendered
new understandings rooted in women’s situational realities. These seemingly
oppositional drivers presented significant management challenges, but the
dialogic relationship also generated a creative tension that spurred innovative
transformations among researchers and community women alike. This propelled new
synergies at the grassroots, especially opening public discursive spaces for
women to share experiences, views, and analyses of power, and, based on these,
to devise indigenous strategies appropriate in their contexts.
Read more: WEMC Final report pages 37-43 »
C.
SUSTAINABILITY
The
integration of WEMC’s work into existing programmes of partners and
collaborating groups through capacity-building in research as well as advocacy
helps to ensure the continued sharing of WEMC concepts, findings and analysis
thus far. The fact that WEMC research findings and outputs are being used by a
diverse set of government authorities in every component ensures sustained
policy impact. Perhaps most importantly, the 27 new groups catalysed by WEMC
and the reorientation of numerous other civil society groups and initiatives
ensures a widening impact into the future.
WEMC Key
Partners and their local associated partners will continue to promote diverse
products in various languages. The WEMC website will be maintained and managed
by Shirkat Gah –Women’s Resource Centre through other funding to enable
continued access to WEMC products: papers, policy briefs, video documentaries
and webcasts as well as draft papers The WLUML Farsi website will publish
selected WEMC products, including articles in the newly launched on-line Farsi
journal “WLUML Journal of Feminist Studies”.