WUNRN
Direct Link to 42-Page UNRISD 2010
Publication:
Registration (free) may be
requested.
Harmonizing
Global Care Policy?
Care and
the Commission on the Status of Women
Author:
Kate
Bedford
In
March 2009 Member States of the United Nations met in New York at the
Commission on the Status of Women (CSW) to discuss, among other things, the
priority theme of “The equal sharing of responsibilities between women and men,
including care-giving in the context of HIV/AIDS”. This meeting provided an
unprecedented opportunity to focus the international community’s attention on
care issues and to generate Agreed Conclusions that would lay out a roadmap for
care policy, potentially influencing national legislation, policies adopted by
UN entities and future international agreements. Using interviews with
participants and an overview of official documentation, this paper seeks to
summarize the achievements of the 2009 CSW, and to suggest where policy
conversations about care might usefully focus next.
More specifically, the paper aims to contribute to three key objectives: (i)
identify the narrative(s) of how the policy frame of equal sharing of
responsibilities, including care-giving in the context of HIV/AIDS, came into
being; (ii) identify the policy alliances generated through that frame; and
(iii) identify the key achievements forged at the 53rd session, while examining
what the Agreed Conclusions might make possible to say and do around care
issues in the future. In this way it aims to provide a supportive and critical
examination of the emerging global policy agenda on care issues as crystallized
in the meetings around the 2009 CSW.
With regard to the achievements, the paper argues that the frame of care,
linked as it was to the equal sharing of responsibility between men and women,
proved an exceptionally expansive one. It successfully united a wide range of
actors, including conservative faith-based actors who had mobilized against
other gender equality initiatives in the past. This expansive frame facilitated
three key advances in care policy at the 53rd session: (i) consensus among
Member States and other actors on the significance of care across the UN
system, especially in relation to HIV; (ii) consensus on a strong state
responsibility; and (iii) consensus on the centrality of care-givers’
participation in debates over policy. These advances may prove significant in
increasing attention to care within the United Nations, defending care services
from state cutbacks in a recession, and helping civil society actors mobilize
around care, especially as related to HIV. In addition, the agreements made at
the 2009 CSW may represent the emergence of a new consensus around the
importance of economic justice issues in gender equality venues, given the foregrounding
of state services and the challenge to free-market models of growth witnessed
there.
In an attempt to consider where care conversations might usefully focus next,
the paper closes with a discussion of two issues that received less attention at
the 2009 CSW: disability and diversity of family formation. These two issues
are highly relevant to care debates, at the UN level and elsewhere, and can
help move global policy forward in fruitful directions. That said, policy
conversations will need to be reframed to take them into account. This task
will in some ways challenge the consensus on care forged at the 2009 CSW. For
example, the progress made in carrying forward the global gender equality
project via a unifying focus on care is in part based on a consensus about
care-givers as the central actors, a position challenged by disability activism
and scholarship. Likewise, the agreements forged at the 2009 CSW in many ways
entrenched the notion that privatized nuclear family units were a universally
desirable model for care provision, a notion challenged by a range of actors
who recognize the role of extended family members in care, and/or who want to
secure more support for the diverse forms through which care is provided. A
reframing of care debates will be necessary if new alliances with such actors
are to be forged and strengthened. While the paper seeks to explicate the
immense value of the Agreed Conclusions forged at the 2009 CSW for future
efforts to secure care services, it also aims to explore the limitations of
those agreements and highlight the importance of continuing the conversation on
care to grapple with current exclusions.
================================================================
To contact the list administrator, or to leave the list, send an email to:
wunrn_listserve-request@lists.wunrn.com. Thank you.