WUNRN

http://www.wunrn.com

 

Inheritance Rights

 


New Publication "In Search of Equality" now available for download below

© Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions
Agbogbloshie, Accra, Ghana

 

Inheritance is a fundamental issue with regard to how wealth is transferred within a society, and it directly relates to the protection of a woman’s housing and land. It reflects some of the systemic reasons for women’s disproportionately high levels of poverty and housing insecurity around the world.

Women’s rights to inherit housing and land are enshrined under international human rights laws. Protections for women’s equality and rights to non-discrimination are outlined in numerous conventions, covenants and resolutions, which additionally defend women’s rights to housing, land and property ownership, access and control, and the right to inherit on an equal basis with men.

Yet the WHRP has found that under many systems of law and society, women - regardless of their marital status - cannot own or inherit land, property and housing in their own names. The protections of international law often do not reach the ground, obstructed by discriminatory common law, non-accessible judicial systems, and inequitable customary legal systems and traditions.

The reasons why women do not inherit are complicated. It is not only an issue of establishing the necessary legal frameworks that allow women to own and inherit property, although this element is certainly crucial. Gender-biased policies, customary law, traditions, social norms and attitudes that women cannot and should not own housing, land and property independently from a man, all serve to prevent women from realizing their rights to inherit.

In many parts of sub-Saharan Africa, for instance, women produce up to 80 percent of all food, and perform over two thirds of the labour, however, suffer disproportionally the subordinating effect of discriminatory and oppressive laws, customs and traditions, especially as regards to housing and land. In most of this region, men control household land (and the house on that land) because of the deeply ingrained patrilineal system of property ownership. For most women, access to housing, land, and property are entirely dependant on their relation to male relatives. Often, even if women are allowed to own property, they lack control of that land or housing.

Other obstacles also emerge. Poverty and HIV/AIDS play a large role in the realization of inheritance rights. Due to increasing poverty, protections formerly provided (at least on a limited basis) under traditional systems have eroded, and women are even more vulnerable to extreme violations of their rights.

 

© Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions   

Mafraq, Jordan

[view larger image]

New COHRE Publication
"In Search of Equality" (2007)

COHRE’s Women and Housing Rights Programme (WHRP) expanded its research of issues related to women’s inheritance, housing and land rights to the Middle East/North African region, examining Algeria, Egypt, Iran, Jordan, Kuwait, Lebanon, Morocco, Palestine, Tunisia and Turkey. The focus of research was on the legal situation of inheritance rights in these States, as well as women’s actual experiences with respect to inheritance.

Research findings are presented in COHRE's newly released report, In Search of Equality: A Survey of Law and Practice related to Women’s Inheritance Rights in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) Region. The report includes contributions from sister organisations in eight MENA States and reveals the complexity of the issues, identifies causes and consequences of inheritance rights violations, and recommends key changes, based on a human rights framework.

The main finding of the report is that inheritance laws should be reformed to embody full gender equality. Far more challenging will be the eradication of the cultural roots of discriminatory customs, traditions and notions. Education must also take high priority as most women are unaware of their rights."

This report is available for download below.

 

"In Search of Equality" (2007)

A survey of Law and Practice related to Women's Inheritance Rights in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) Region.

pdf download pdf [en]  

 

The Denial of Women's Inheritance Rights in the Middle East, North Africa and sub-Saharan Africa and its impact on the spread of HIV/AIDS etc.
doc download doc [en]  

 

Human Rights Framework

Human rights provide a tool to combat the practices and laws that serve to subordinate women. A human rights framework of action provides both a legal basis for change as well as a people-driven approach for transformation. Human rights, to be truly effective, must be strongly advocated for, strategically applied to law and policies, and purposefully implemented on the ground. It is especially vital for women, a human rights analysis reveals concerns of women themselves, going beyond mere lack of economic or income indicators, and allowing for the inclusion of the phenomena of powerlessness, subordination and social exclusion.

A human rights approach to inheritance provides not only a legal basis for policies and laws which grant women such rights, it also insists that women hold more equal place in the family, that they be given more decision-making power and that they be given equal standing. Their place within families and communities must be recognized, as equal and without discrimination.

Women’s housing rights are enshrined the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights and the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women, and recently, the UN Commission on Human Rights, in its resolution 2003/22 entitled “Women’s equal ownership of, access to and control over land and the equal rights to own property and to adequate housing,” affirmed that discrimination against women with respect to having access to, acquiring and securing land, property and housing, constitutes a violation of women’s human rights to protection against discrimination. The resolution confirmed a woman’s right to inheritance.

 

Inheritance Rights in Sub-Saharan Africa

The countries of Ghana, Senegal, Nigeria, Ethiopia, Rwanda, Zimbabwe, Zambia, Botswana, Swaziland and South Africa were chosen as the subjects of a review of constitutions and national laws related to inheritance and property as well of customary law and traditions that may impact inheritance. The report, titled "Bringing Equality Home" can be downloaded in full from the COHRE Library, Country Reports.

The Project has examined inheritance rights and its effects in the sub-Saharan context. Subject to plural systems of civil and customary law, entrenched patriarchal customs and traditions, and discriminatory societal relationships, women in sub-Saharan Africa are especially vulnerable to violations of their right to inheritance.

The first phase of the project was a research and consultation phase, seeking to uncover and examine the issue of inheritance through human rights, and more concretely a housing rights, framework. A fact-finding mission in August 2003 brought COHRE to South Africa, Zambia and Rwanda, to more fully understand the issues around inheritance as they play out on the ground. A Workshop/Training in January of 2004, brought 27 activists from throughout Sub-Saharan Africa working on inheritance and women’s rights to one table to discuss the issues and obstacles around inheritance, both legally and practically, and to examine the strategies to address those issues. The workshop stressed a human rights perspective and will seek to formulate potential recommendations for improving the inheritance rights of women in the region.

 

"A Place To Live: Women's Inheritance Rights in Africa" (2005)

This short book comes from the longer COHRE report (Bringing Equality Home). It is an easy to read version for ordinary folk so that they can find out about what COHRE and others think should happen to make things better for women.
pdf download pdf [en]  

 

Phase II of the Inheritance Rights Project

Phase II is designed to continue the momentum of the currently underway sub-Saharan Africa Inheritance Rights Project. This project will take the issue further and research additional countries, focused on the Middle East and North Africa, and a variety of contexts, such as Islam generally; personal law, or the Moudawana; strict patriarchal regimes; poverty and economic disempowerment; and traditions and customs.

The Middle East and North Africa Phase of the Project aims to look at ten countries, focusing on three for fact-finding missions, to investigate the issue of inheritance and its effects on women at a ground level. The countries chosen are Turkey, Jordan, Kuwait, Lebanon, Palestine, Iran, Egypt, Tunisia, Morocco and Algeria. Phase II will be carried out in a similar fashion to Phase I in Sub-Saharan Africa, namely through research, networking, fact finding missions and a training/workshop.

The Project will culminate with a Conference, or Summit, of representatives from each region, to come together to discuss common themes and strategies on inheritance, housing and land rights, to form a more global effort towards combating discriminatory inheritance rights law and practices, as well as bring important attention to the issue.

Through this Project, it is hoped that the issue of inheritance may be regarded from a new perspective, and improved within a context of existing international legal obligations and standards. Investigating inheritance laws and practices though a human rights perspective will provide a framework for innovative and sustainable solutions. Key is ongoing and innovative advocacy on the issue, both sensitizing the public on the intricacies of the issue and a need for change in practice, and working with governments and officials to achieve such a change in law and policy, both within the at issue ME/NA region and the sub-Saharan Africa region





================================================================
To leave the list, send your request by email to: wunrn_listserve-request@lists.wunrn.com. Thank you.