SCALING UP WOMEN'S PARTICIPATION IS KEY TO SUSTAINABLE DISASTER
PREVENTION AND PREPAREDNESS.
MAINSTREAM INTERVENTIONS FOR DISASTER REDUCTION SHOULD ESSENTIALLY BUILD
ON EXISTING RESILIENCE DEMONSTRATED AMPLY BY WOMEN AND POOR COMMUNITIES.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
RECOGNISE & POLICY SUPPORT WOMEN AS KEY ACTORS IN DISASTER RISK
REDUCTION INSTEAD OF AS VICTIMS.
TOGTHER WITH ADDRESSING GENDER CONCERNS IN THE CONTEXT OF DISASTERS,
TO MINIMISE WASTAGE, MAXIMISE INFRASTRUCTURE & DEVELOPMENT
INVESTMENTS AND IT'S MAINTENANCE, IN DISASTER RELIEF AND RECONSTRUCTION,
POLICY & PROGRAM SUPPORT NEEDED
Ø WOMEN NEED ADEQUATE REPRESENTATION AT ALL LEVELS OF DECISION MAKING
Ø WOMEN'S SELF HELP GROUPS ACCESS TO CAPACITIES & RESOURCES FOR
LIVELIHOODS
Ø WOMEN SHGs TO PLAY KEY ROLES IN RELIEF COORDINATION, RECOVERY PLANS
FOR HOUSING &SERVICES AND SUSTAIN REHABILITATION RESULTS TOWARDS SUSTAINABLE
DEVELOPMENT
If we are to shift the focus from relief to disaster prevention scaling
up women's participation is essential. At the gender and social issues session
at the IDMC, wide range of innovations and policy initiatives emerged for
scaling up women's participation emerged with clear directions for government
and international support.
Over 100 representatives belonging to field NGOs, SHG /federation
leaders, gender and development professionals, academics, researchers and from
over 12 states recognised the undervalued yet valuable role of grassroots -CBOs,
women's self help groups esp. in the context of in response and rehabilitation
esp. after the tsunami and the floods in Western India after listening to the
key speakers.
The session was viewed as a platform for debate using presentations that
highlighted the role of women in response and rehabilitation esp. after the
tsunami and the floods in Western India.
It was heartening to note the many examples of interventions from floods
in Maharashtra, W.Bengal, Orissa and tsunami in Tamilnadu stressing the need to
recognize the role of women as responders and actors in relief and
rehabilitation.
Dr Vinod Menon , Member NDMA, in his opening remarks, stressed that the
entire process of disaster management needs to be Reshaped. Restoration of
normalcy is not the best way to respond in disaster situation. Disaster offers
an opportunity for not only bringing back normalcy, but also Building Back
Better. Rehabilitation in post disaster situation should not be only restricted
to physical re-construction. Far more importance should give to reconstruction
of lives by supporting women and community participation and consolidating the
social processes.
Chairperson highlighted that wherever women's self help groups were
supported in large numbers by the government the results are tremendous in
changing the status of women and in reducing corruption and bringing efficacy in
the rehabilitation process. Example of 2400 groups with Rs. 40 crores turnover
in tsunami affected Nagapattinam district -as reported by leader of
fisherwomen's Federation were ready for playing active role in disaster
prevention.
Relief
Women should not be treated merely as victims but as partners in changes
as the knowledge resource is with community as what is going on in their local
settings.
Presenter from Tsunami affected areas pointed out that damage assessments
does not include economic losses, losses of most vulnerable groups eg Dalits and
tribal communities and agricultural farmers.
"One blanket does not fit all." In the relief phase, cash
compensation/assets should be actually routed thru women's groups. Need of joint
ownership of titles and property was stressed.
Presentation that highlights the need for a shift in disaster policy and
intervention. With respect to clear recognition that gender dimension to
disaster response is important. Practical needs, of women and girls, do not get
considered when a disaster strikes due to emergency response based on formula of
one-blanket fits all. Besides addressing practical aspects, strategically
involving women in relief phase could reduce corruption, ensure information flow
to affected citizens and hold agencies and Panchayats accountable.
A government official in her speech clearly identified that deaths and
identification of women and senior citizens are not taken care of. The actual
data compilation and social assessment can be done only by those closes to the
community and people. This gives opportunity for women's groups, Gram Panchayats
and CBOs to intervene properly.
Role of women self help groups
From all presentations, it was seen that self help groups have played an
implementation role - in search and rescue, community kitchens, grain banks,
providing credit, in village level, decision making, identifying livelihoods,
forming disaster task forces etc.
Women's groups faced extreme opposition from traditional male dominated
community leaders. Support of NGOs was crucial in bringing women out and in
involving them in addressing vulnerabilities.
Facilitators or Doers - Role of NGOs, Govt
In the post tsunami response and rehabilitation -it was demonstrated once
again that technical assistance professionals, NGOs and international donors
should take on facilitation instead of playing an intermediary, implementing
role. It was noted widely, that reducing women & communities and their
organisations to project beneficiaries undermines their potential role in
disaster prevention.
The tsunami offers a hitherto under-utilised opportunity to strengthen
grassroots women's economic status while providing opportunity to recognise and
train them managers in disaster risk reduction.
In a charity driven environment, some Govt, NGOs and practitioners have
facilitated GPs, SHGs and CBOs for local ownership initiatives. These
initiatives offer powerful insights for policy support required for the next
stage to move towards disaster prevention. Community should live together and
stay together.
Recommendations presented by Chair : Prema Gopalan in the valedictory
session
RECOMMENDATIONS - 1
Disaster Preparedness & Prevention
- Positioning women as key actors / leaders in DRR initiatives at all
levels - Build on adaptive / risk sharing capacities of SHGs / CBOs - Women
(SHGs / CBOs) mandatory for community based disaster management plans - Gender
disaggregated data for multi-level policy planning and preparedness (NSS,
Census)
RECOMMENDATIONS - 2
Policy & Governance
- Adequate budgetary provision (of at least 10% )for vulnerability
reduction measures benefiting women - Adequate representation of women (from
SHGs / CBOs) in disaster management authorities at all levels - Social +
financial audit of planning for ensuring equitable access - Design Relief +
Compensation Packages for Women and Girls - Joint ownership of assets a
precondition of rehabilitation - Formal responsibility to SHGs & CBOs for
handling relief -volunteers, cash assistance, shelter management,food
procurement & supply,para-medical teams, etc
RECOMMENDATIONS - 3
Communication
- Ensure transparency & reduce corruption through information flow
& redressal mechanisms - Access to communication tools to ensure last mile
coverage in early warning systems for preparedness - Train PRIs to integrate
risk reduction in development works
Livelihoods & Insurance
- Involve women to ensure in design, management & maintenance of
community infrastructure and assets - Financial products and sustained
investments for livelihoods & enterprise promotion - Affordable &
responsive life & non-life micro insurance for assets, livestock, crops etc.
- Swayam Shikshan Prayog, December 2006