By Benjamin Harvey
As the sun rose over the southern city
Gaziantep one summer morning, Selahattin Sezgin, 22, decided it was time
to kill his sister.
The 16-year-old girl was unmarried and pregnant
- and that was enough to seal her fate. While his neighbours slept, Sezgin
pulled out a pump-action shotgun and fired it into her chest and head, a
murder for which he will spend the rest of his life in prison.
But
to many in Turkey, he is not a criminal.
"If a girl lays with a man
or cheats, her mother won't want her," said Abdulkerim Aslan, an
unemployed 47-year-old Istanbul resident. "It brings shame on the family.
Either the girl has to leave, or the stain has to be cleaned."
Turkey's longstanding quest to join the European Union
has entailed dramatic and sometimes wrenching changes: greater civil
liberties, painful economic reforms, a crackdown on corruption. But the
practice Turks call Honor killings has proved one of the most difficult to
eradicate, despite tough new laws enacted under pressure from
Brussels.
The issue is complicated by the fact that the murders are
associated mainly with the Kurdish minority - which the EU and human
rights groups view as victims of oppressive policies by the Turkish
state.
Brussels has been sympathetic to Kurdish demands that Turkey
grant them more cultural freedoms. But many of Turkey's image problems -
the perception that it tolerates backward practices at odds with the West
-stem from the Kurds' fiercely guarded clan-based way of life.
To
some Kurds, the government's efforts to satisfy the Europeans over Honor
killings is just another example of interference by an overbearing Turkish
state.
"This comes from our ancestors," said Mehmet Yolac said,
claiming Honor killings as a Kurdish tradition as he ironed a pair of
pants in his tailoring shop in the largely Kurdish Istanbul neighbourhood
of Esentepe. He added proudly: "We're passionate about our
Honor."
According to the rigid Honor code embraced by Kurds like
Sezgin, a man is judged not only by his actions but by the fidelity and
chastity of the women in his life.
That viewpoint is not unique to
Kurds. A study published in March by Bosporus University professor Hakan
Yilmaz found that men across Turkey define their Honor by their wife's
chastity more than anything else.
But it is within the Kurds'
patriarchal social structure that such attitudes are taken most seriously
- and most often spill into violence.
Kurds from the southeast have
been migrating by the tens of thousands into Western cities like Istanbul,
bringing with them village traditions that put them in conflict with the
part of the country that is self-consciously pushing itself to be more
liberal, more open, more European.
Feleknas Uca, a Kurdish member
of the European Parliament, believes that ending the killings and becoming
more "European" requires Turkey to address the problems of its Kurdish
population in a deep and fundamental way - to inculcate them into the ways
of the West.
One obstacle may be the deep distrust that meets even
the best of Turkish intentions. For decades, Kurds have complained of
discrimination, and they have suffered through more than two decades of
fighting between autonomy-seeking Kurdish guerrillas and Turkish
forces.
The government has acted aggressively to legitimise
violence against women.
It revamped the penal code in 2005 so men
can no longer claim they were provoked to kill by a woman's immorality,
and imposed life sentences for Honor killings regardless of the murderer's
age - to prevent family members from forcing a younger son to commit the
crime and be tried as a minor.
But the sense of obligation to
maintain Honor is so deeply ingrained among Kurds that even the harshest
penalties are unlikely to be a deterrent. There are often reports of men
crying over the dead body of a daughter or sister, wailing that they were
forced to carry out the slaying.
Recently, families have taken to
finding other ways to achieve the same end: pressuring the girl to kill
herself. Such suicides are now regular occurrences in parts of eastern
Turkey, though precise statistics are unavailable because records are poor
and families often disguise the deaths.
There has been rash of
forced suicides in the southeastern city of Batman, population 250 000;
the UN has recorded at least three dozen there so far in
2006.
Precise figures on the proportion of Honor killings committed
by Kurds are unavailable because Turkey does not recognise the Kurds as a
distinct ethnic minority. But police statistics indicate the killings are
largely a Kurdish phenomenon.
Though they make up an estimated 20
percent of Turkey's population, 43 percent of the crimes police classified
as Honor killings from 2000-2005 occurred in the east or southeast of the
country, where Kurds are predominant. Of the remaining Honor killings
committed in the west, 45 percent were committed by people who were
originally from the east or southeast.
Nebahat Akkoc, a Kurdish
woman who founded the Ka-Mer women's centre headquartered in Diyarbakir,
Turkey's largest Kurdish-majority city, said it would take time to change
attitudes toward Honor killings.
"The laws changed fast here," she
said. "The problem is that efforts to change the mentality have been very
insufficient."
Sapa-AP |