Home | Issues | HR Guide | Documents | Archive | Links | About this Resource |
Great Ancestors - Women Asserting Rights in Muslim
Contexts 2005, 2 volume Kit (Training Manual: 133 pages;
Narratives: 193 pages)
Author: Farida Shaheed, with Aisha Lee-Shaheed Order from: Shirkat Gah pubs@sgah.org.pk or WLUML pubs@wluml.org
Price (exclusive of postage and packing): Global South: $15; Global North: $30 Book Review
by Anissa Helie
The international solidarity network Women Living Under Muslim Laws (WLUML)1 and the Lahore-based women's collective Shirkat Gah (also acting as the WLUML Regional Coordination office for Asia) have undertaken a ground breaking historical research. Its aim is to reclaim women's rights activism as grounded in Muslim societies. The resulting publication - the Great Ancestors, Women Asserting Rights in Muslim Contexts - highlights the lives and deeds of women from diverse Muslim countries and communities who have, in the past, engaged in the struggle for gender equality. Richly illustrated, it provides dozens of examples of women's rights advocates ranging from the 8th century to the 1950s and encompasses regions as varied as the Arabian Peninsula, Egypt, Muslim Spain, India, Pakistan, Algeria, Iran, Turkey, Central Asia, Nigeria or Indonesia. In the words of the author, Farida Shaheed from Pakistan, the research allows to connect "the contemporary struggle for women's rights [with our] historical past, engendering a sense of linkage with - and ownership of - both women's assertions in the past and the contemporary movement." Feminism belongs to all The impetus for the project came from a need to challenge a common assumption that defines feminism as a project which originated in the West in the course of the last couple of centuries. This misconception, combined with the portrayal in mainstream Western media of "Muslim women" as passive victims, serves the proponents of the so-called clash of civilizations - who would like us to believe that boundaries of identities negates the very possibility of a global feminist agenda. On the other hand, it also serves the interests of the religious Right in Muslim countries and communities. These politico-religious forces ("fundamentalists") systematically denounce feminism as a foreign discourse and practice. The goal is to de-legitimize feminists as "Westernized" women who betray their culture or religion by opting for a "non-indigenous" strategy. It is clear that the challenges women faced (and continue to face) are influenced by historical, social and political circumstances, and that the strategies they designed (individually or collectively) are, accordingly, varied. Yet, Great Ancestors sets to demonstrate that the efforts undertaken by women towards achieving gender equality in Muslim contexts have been ongoing for centuries. In the process, it "explodes the myth that struggles for women's rights are alien to societies that embraced Islam." The wealth of illustrations - from portraits to covers of 19th century women's magazines to reproductions of early miniatures, some of them exquisite - also goes a long way in making this statement not only politically valuable but also enjoyable for the eye. Documenting women's struggles in Muslim contexts - A WLUML approach Reclaiming a feminist past in Muslim contexts is not a new endeavor. For more than a decade already, scholars have documented prominent female figures, or focused their research on women's activism in a given region. For example, Margot Badran has translated the Memoirs of Hoda Shaarawi, an early Egyptian feminist leader (Harem Years - 1879/1924). Badran subsequently drew upon a wide range of women's sources (memoirs, letters, essays, journalistic articles, fiction, treatises, and extensive oral histories) to record the spread of feminism at the turn of the last century in Egypt in her Feminists, Islam, and Nation: Gender and the Making of Modern Egypt (1996). Other well-known researchers include Fatima Mernissi in Morocco, who brought back to life the Forgotten Queens of Islam (1993). Or Kumari Jayawardena in Sri Lanka, whose research on women's political struggles from the last 19th century onwards did include women in some Muslim countries (Feminism and Nationalism in the Third World, reprint 1994). Yet, Great Ancestors adds an international dimension to this previous scholarship. In addition to its stated aim to uncover an "indigenous" feminist past that can inspire younger generations of activists, it also differs from earlier work at other levels. The unique format will prove invaluable to women's advocates, trainers and educators alike. The 2 volume kit offers, on the one hand, a narrative part which is organized chronologically from the 8th century till the contemporary period. Varied illustrations enrich the almost 200 pages of text. The "Narratives" portray women according to the specific area of activism on which they focused. The scope of their activities is an eye opener - reminding us that a number of issues (such as polygyny, divorce rights, child custody, etc.) remain sites of struggle to this day. Shaheed underlines three main "strands of women's assertiveness" - at times interconnected, at times developing independently from one another: "The first strand consist of women asserting control over their personal lives, especially in terms of bodily integrity, including sexuality, and rights within the family. The second, much less documented strand is women's solidarity actions, that is, initiatives by women to support other women. The third strand is women's efforts to improve their societies."2 Some women worked towards ensuring access to education (for themselves or others) and thrived on intellectual achievements or the knowledge of scriptures. Others fought to secure rights within marriage or refused the marriage institution altogether. Yet others engaged in collective solidarity projects, including anti-colonial struggles or early forms of transnational feminist networking. For the reader, the combination of chronological and thematic within the "Narratives" (as well as the index) makes the various chapters easy to navigate. The second volume of the kit - the "Training Module" - also mirrors the three broad "strands" of women's activism. It provides texts and illustrations (as well as guidelines and glossary) that are specifically designed for teachers and trainers to run a one hour training session. The Training Module's script, to be read aloud, offers a series of monologues/cameos either based on original sources or, where possible, using women's own voices. These concrete examples of women's activism, each lasting no more than 60 seconds so as to keep attention focused, start with the provocative sentence: "How could you have forgotten me?". Indeed, participants will no doubt wonder how so many powerful women could have been silenced and made invisible throughout history. The content is also original in terms of its
orientation. It also, deliberately, does not limit itself to "Muslim women" - for two reasons. First, because WLUML is aware that there were, and there are, non-Muslim women who live and struggle in Muslim contexts. Second, and importantly, because there are women from Muslim backgrounds who - whether they are believers or not - choose other markers of identity than religion. Finally, Great Ancestors includes some male voices, to pay tribute to the men who took a stand in favor of gender equality and advocated for women's rights. As Farida Shaheed emphasizes: "The notion that all men in Muslim societies are misogynistic is as much a myth as the notion that women are only silent victims."4 Sources and Limitations Historical sources rarely do justice to women's struggles. Apart from the recurrent issue of male monopoly over knowledge, there may also be the fact (at least in some contexts such as sub-Saharan Africa) that a number of societies tended to rely on oral rather than written traditions. However, in the early days of Islam (during the 8th and 9th centuries), various historical data do include prominent women. Shaheed notes that, among the 4,250 names entered in the earliest Tabaqat al-kubra (the "First Generations" - a record of important figures), about 15% are women. Between the 11th and 15th centuries, scholars continue to record the lives of Muslims from royal and elite families - but now also move towards documenting less affluent or influential people. This includes "women merchants, poets, midwives", etc. The geographical range increases as well: early works focus initially on Mecca and Medina later ones, starting from the 14th century, also mention women from Egypt to Syria. But, from the 15th century onwards, "women mysteriously disappear". In the 16th century Al-Ghazzi's (died 1651) compilation of 1,647 illustrious people includes only 12 women. In the 17th century, Al-Muhibbi (d. 1699) lists no women at all. In the 18th century, Al-Muradi (d.1791) refers to one single woman. And in 19th century, Al-Baytar (d.1918) mentions only two women. What happened? Badran situates the time when "notable women [began to] rapidly drop out of Islamic history" earlier, possibly linking it to the increased practice of concubinage around the 10th and 11th centuries. She states: "The 'Abbâsids [832-950] preferred having concubines to wives. Wives were free Muslim women who could exercise their rights, while concubines were slaves with few rights. The emphasis on concubinage affected the whole society and engendered attitudes that canceled the exercise of women's rights and freedom."5 More research would help establish whether this was one of the early factors which led to women's exclusion from historical records. For the 15th to 19th century period, court records would have no doubt offered a wealth of information, as many women took advantage of legal means at their disposal to settle disputes (as a delicate 13th century miniature from Baghdad shows, with a wife and husband consulting a qadi, or magistrate). But the Great Ancestors's small team could not take advantage of such sources - at least not for this volume (it is conceived of as an ongoing project). Another limitation, acknowledged by the authors, is linked to the fact that the research relied primarily on information available in English or Urdu - leaving unexplored large sections of the "Muslim world" (such as Chinese, Indonesian Muslims or communities from sub-Saharan Africa and Europe, etc). However, overall, Great Ancestors proves to be an exciting, well researched, and attractively illustrated book. Hopefully, the present publication will encourage groups with access to local data to undertake further research in other countries. Reclaiming history is an endeavor most oppressed constituencies - from indigenous to women, from gays and lesbians to disabled people - are engaged in. By documenting their own great ancestors, such groups are able to trace the roots of their activism, and sustain contemporary struggles. Similarly, a large-scale history of feminism in the Muslim world6 can go a long way in confronting the challenges posed to women by foreign intervention, the failure of nation states to provide for citizens' basic needs or the rise of the Muslim religious right. Notes
|